Is YouTube killing small channels? The short answer is NO. But there are some huge things that often slip the minds of small creators who try to grow.
We’ve seen hundreds of small channels. Some climb out of nowhere. Others stall for months, post after post, wondering why nothing sticks.
And every time YouTube rolls out a new feature, we hear the same question echo across forums and creator chats: “Is YouTube still worth it if you're small?”
Let’s talk about that.
Because while growth is harder than ever (competition is no joke), YouTube is also doing more than it used to. And some of those updates genuinely shift the odds.
First, What’s Actually Getting Better for Small Creators?
YouTube’s not perfect. But if you’re only seeing the complaints and algorithm rants, here’s what you might’ve missed.
The Hype feature for instance. It's one of the most useful tools for small creators YouTube’s rolled out in years.
- Viewers can “hype” a video from a channel with fewer than 500,000 subs
- Those videos show up in a country-specific leaderboard with a shiny badge
- And smaller channels get a points multiplier.
In Brazil, Taiwan, and Turkey, this led to over 5 million hypes across 50,000 channels. That’s real visibility - powered by the people, not just the algorithm.
There is also YouTube’s Posts tab (ex Community tab) - once a gated feature - is now rolling out to more smaller creators. Threshold lowered to 500 subs.
That means:
- You can engage your audience with text, polls, and behind-the-scenes content.
- And build loyalty between uploads.
This shows that YouTube’s trying, but…
So Why Do Small Creators Still Tank?
Here’s the hard part. It’s not always your fault.
But it’s rarely just the algorithm’s fault either.
The system is harder than it used to be. More competition, shorter attention spans, higher standards. You can do everything “right” and still feel stuck.
Some content creators are failing because they’re skipping the stuff that matters long before the algorithm ever gets a say.
And what you should look at depends heavily on the type of content you make.
Let’s break it down.
YouTube Algorithm is Not the Same for All Niches
Let’s look at some real patterns from MilX users across different niches.
What’s MilX?
MilX is a free financial app YouTubers use to get extra cash and transfer their funds via 10 different methods in 40+ currencies, including crypto. If you’re already earning on YouTube, download the free MilX app - it makes the financial side easier.
Let’s break the YouTube algorithm down by format.
Podcast Channels → Watch Time is King
One long-form interview channel connected to MilX kept seeing low CTR - but it didn’t matter. Why?
Because people who clicked were watching 40–50 minutes out of 90. That sent a powerful signal:
"This video is keeping users on YouTube."
That’s what the algorithm wants.
So if you’re doing deep conversations or commentary. Don’t stress too much over click-through.
Instead, focus on pacing, guest energy, and cutting filler early.
Meme & Entertainment Shorts → CTR, Shares, and Completion Rate
Entertaining Shorts live and die in the first 3 seconds. If you don’t stop the scroll instantly, you’re out.
And if people share your content, the algorithm pays attention. Even more than likes.
One MilX user uploaded a 20-second meme Short that viewers watched all the way through.
It wasn’t just the watch time - it was the replays, shares, and high CTR that made it spike. Short-form comedy thrives on that combo: fast hooks + emotional payoff + shareability.
If you’re in memes or short entertainment:
- Start with movement or a punchline setup - no intro screens;
- Add captions for sound-off viewers;
- Track which Shorts get shared the most and double down on that pacing.
Music Channels → Replays & Shares Matter More
A 3-minute music video isn’t going to win on watch time alone. It’s too short.
But one MilX user we saw was getting hit after hit not because of high retention, but because of repeat views and playlist saves.
People were rewatching. Sharing. Embedding it.
That’s what YouTube sees as sticky content.
So if you're in music, ask:
- Are people looping the track?
- Are they commenting “on repeat”?
- Are they saving it to their own playlists?
That’s your signal. Not average view duration.
Educational Channels → Retention Drop-off is Brutal
We saw a language education creator who had solid topics and thumbnails. But 70% of viewers dropped off in the first 90 seconds.
The intro was too slow. Too much explanation. No value delivered fast enough.
Once she restructured the videos - examples first, context later - she retained 70% of viewers past minute 10 on a 15-minute video.
That’s retention that feeds the algorithm.
So if you're teaching something:
- Hook fast with a clear takeaway;
- Show, then explain;
- Cut everything that doesn’t get people to minute 5.
Gaming Channels → Watch Time + Viewer Reactions Matter
Gaming is tricky. The audience loves long content. 30-minute let’s plays, full streams, walkthroughs. But that doesn’t mean longer is always better.
One MilX user uploaded two Minecraft videos.
- First: 30 minutes long, but viewers dropped off after 5 minutes.
- Second: 15 minutes, with 10 minutes of average watch time.
Guess which one YouTube picked up?
The one with tighter pacing, better retention, and more likes and comments.
Because in gaming, the algorithm looks for strong average watch time and clear viewer signals like likes and active comment threads.
If you're in gaming:
- Edit. Trim downtime and slow intros
- Use comment pins to ask questions (“What would you build next?”)
- Shorten your uploads and track which segment gets most rewatched
TL;DR:
Your analytics aren’t there to tell you how you did.
They’re there to tell you why it worked - or didn’t. Let’s get deeper on that.
Already earning on YouTube?
You don’t have to wait for the 21st. With the free MilX app, you can access your earnings anytime - even unlock future income upfront. To qualify, you just need 1,500+ subscribers and 5,000 watch hours in the past year.
Read the Analytics Right – The Way To Win
Views aren’t the full story for small channels.YouTube looks deeper into how people watch, not just how many.
If you’re a small creator and your channel’s flatlining, here’s what to fix.
Are People Clicking? CTR – Click-Through Rate
The algorithm needs a reason to test your video in the first place. That starts with the packaging. If people aren’t clicking, it never gets a shot.
What to fix:
- Use “Test & Compare” to A/B test thumbnails
- Make titles that ask a clear question or tease a mystery - not both
- Show real emotion or tension in your thumbnail (close-ups work)
- Avoid clutter. No more than 3–4 words in a thumbnail
Are They Staying? Retention & Average View Duration
A click isn’t the win. Keeping them watching is. The first 30 seconds are everything. That’s where most viewers bounce if you don’t hook fast. And YouTube’s watching that curve closely.
What to fix:
- Cut your first 15 seconds like a trailer. Don’t waste time;
- Drop in visual or audio pattern breaks every 20–30 seconds;
- Cut what doesn’t serve the core point;
- Keep intros under 8 seconds unless your audience expects long-form;
- Try writing your ending first, then designing your hook to tease it.
Are They Coming Back? Repeat Views, Shares, Playlist Adds
If someone replays your video, adds it to a playlist, or shares it - YouTube sees that as trust. That’s a better signal than even likes.
What to fix:
- Build your videos as part of a series or content loop;
- Use pinned comments and end screens to lead viewers to the next piece;
- Check which moments get rewatched and repeat that energy or format;
- End your video with: “If this helped, watch this next → [Title]”;
- Ask for saves: “Add this to your playlist if you’ll need it again later”.
Are You Even Being Seen? Traffic Sources
If 90% of your views come from subscribers or direct links - you’re in a bubble. You want traffic from Search, Suggested, Browse. That’s where new growth happens.
What to fix:
- Write titles that match what people search. VidIQ could help with that;
- Create topic clusters. 3+ videos on the same theme;
- Use end screens and pinned comments to boost session time;
- Optimize descriptions and tags around viewer intent;
- Double down on formats that already pull in Suggested traffic.
Are You Mixing Your Formats? Long-form, Shorts, Streams
If you’re only making one type of content, you’re limiting how many doors people can enter through. YouTube favors creators who show up across multiple surfaces - Shorts, long-form, and even streams.
Some of the MilX users growing fastest now run 24/7 loops of old content.
What to fix:
- Chop long videos into Shorts with a cliffhanger;
- Try 24/7 looping of your best videos to boost exposure;
- Mix formats weekly: how-to → stream → Short → follow-up;
- Use Shorts to tease the bigger story, not just summarize it;
- Check which format brings you new viewers - then double down.
Are You Using the Community Tab to Stay Alive Between Uploads?
YouTube’s Posts tab is a growth tool disguised as a side feature. Polls, images, memes, questions. All of that keeps the channel active even when you’re not posting videos. And now it’s unlocked at just 500 subs.
What to fix:
- Run polls to test video titles or angles before filming;
- Post at least 2–3 times a week to stay visible in feeds;
- Reply to comments to boost engagement - it matters;
- Tease new uploads, ask questions, and share WIPs or context;
- Treat it like a group chat, not a bulletin board.
Need Extra Cash to Grow Faster?
If you’re already earning on YouTube, MilX helps you move like a big channel - even if you’re not one (yet).
MilX is a free finance app for creators that lets you:
- Unlock up to 6 months of your future YouTube income;
- Get paid before payday;
- Withdraw in 40+ currencies (yes, crypto too);
- Send money to your editor or collaborators instantly - with 0% fees.
Thousands of creators use MilX to upgrade gear, boost content, and scale faster, without waiting for YouTube’s payout cycle.
Power up your channel with MilX.
Before You Go
YouTube’s not killing small creators.
But the gap between “uploading videos” and “building a channel” has never been wider.
The creators who grow today… They test. They tweak. They read the data.
And yeah, they use every tool YouTube gives them - including the ones most people ignore.
Want to be one of the ones who breaks through?
Start there.